Ways to make holiday pies lower in sugar, calories, and fat
How To Make Holiday Pies With Less Sugar, Calories, And Fat
Share the post
Share this link via
Or copy link

Gettyimages.com/Grandmother, mother and daughter making an apple pie — Image by � Beau Lark/Corbis
Pies are a traditional part of most American holiday meals. Between Thanksgiving and New Year’s Eve, you’ll see quite a few of these round desserts. They’re usually fruit-based and they’re just so innocent looking—how bad could they really be for your waistline? Well, pretty bad, depending on which ones you’re eating. While an apple pie may just look like apple slices in a crust, it’s probably made with a gooey filling that is all butter and sugar. Then there’s the crust, which is usually made with white flour—an enemy of your blood sugar. But, at the end of the day, you want to feel like you got to partake in the holiday festivities so you grab a slice of the apple pie, then the pumpkin pie, and let’s not forget the berry crumble. It may be time to learn to make these sweet circular treats healthier. Here are ways to make holiday pies lower in sugar, calories, and fat.

Image Source: Shutterstock
Make your own whole wheat crust
Your filling is so sweet and delicious that you don’t even taste the crust. So give yourself some fiber points by making a whole wheat crust. You can even mix in a little bran for berry pies.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Image Source: Shutterstock
Don’t add a top crust
While traditional pies contain a top crust, that’s just a lot of extra dough that you don’t need. Plus, the top crust takes away from your delicious filling so make a topless pie.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Image Source: Shutterstock
Use coconut toppings
If you love having your whipped cream or vanilla ice cream on top of pie (who doesn’t?) opt for coconut milk-based toppings. These are lower in sugar, fat, and calories than dairy toppings.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Image Source: Shutterstock
Grind fiber cereal into your graham crust
If you love graham cracker crust, swap out half of the graham crackers for your favorite high fiber cereal. Just blend the cereal up with the graham crackers when making your crust.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow
Add flax seed to your crust
Crush up flax seeds and blend them into your crust. You’ll get some healthy fats and fiber points.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Credit: Bigstock
Add spices instead of sugar
Play with spices to see if you can cut back on sugar. Nutmeg, cinnamon, and ginger will all add a burst of flavor to your filling without adding sugar.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Image Source: Shutterstock
Swap Greek yogurt for butter
Swap out a portion of your butter in your crust for Greek yogurt. It’s just as creamy, but it’s lower in calories and can give your pie a protein boost.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Bigstockphoto.com/Nuts mix in a wooden plate
Add crushed walnuts to your crust
You probably already put nuts in some of your pies, so incorporate them into your crust. You can even use your beloved white flour if you swap out about a quarter of it and replace it with blended up walnuts or pecans.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow
Spray your pan with coconut oil
Instead of spraying or coating your pie pan with butter, coat it with coconut oil. You can even coat it with heart healthy olive oil for nutty pies (it will blend with the savory taste well).
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Image Source: Shutterstock
Use soft tofu for creampies
If you love creampies—from chocolate pudding to banana cream—then you need all the help you can get in cutting calories. Substitute some of your pudding or cream mix with soft tofu. It is flavorless so it won’t take away from the taste of your pie.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Image Source: Shutterstock
Use almond milk and mashed bananas in creampies
Another way to cut calories in creampies is by using almond milk. If you’re making a banana cream pie, don’t forget that ripe bananas are plenty creamy without added pudding or cream. Just blend them up finely and you can cut back on the pudding.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Image Source: Shutterstock
Try quinoa flour
Quinoa flour gives you fiber and protein points in your crust. It has a light flavor that makes it a good introductory flour when moving away from traditional white flour.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Bigstockphoto.com/Fruit and berry crumble cake with oat and wholemeal topping
Go entirely crustless
You can skip the crust altogether and have a carb-free pie. Or, you can make a crumble with a topping that’s a mixture of crushed flax seeds, nuts, and high fiber cereal.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Image Source: Shutterstock
Choose high fiber fruits
Go for high fiber fruits like raspberries, blueberries, rubarb, and blackberries. A little will go a long way with these in filling you up.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow

Source: Shutterstock
Make flatter pies
People decide the size of their pie slice based on width not depth. If you make a pie that is four inches thick or one that is one inch thick, you’ll cut the same width of slice either way. So make thinner pies and trick your eye.
- Protected: The Sound Of Movement: Ledisi Reflects On The Power Of Protest Music And Self-Love In ‘The Crown’
- 5 Beyoncé Hairstyles To Complete Your ‘Cowboy Carter’ Tour Look
- Celebrity Hairstylist Dee Michelle Talks Hair Health & Her Invisible K-Tip Method
- Boop, There It Is! Tony Nominee Jasmine Amy Rogers Is Making History As Broadway’s First Black Betty Boop — And She’s Just Getting Started [Exclusive]
- Gym Etiquette 101: 10 Rules Every Respectful Member Should Follow
-
Love Or Liability? How Romantic Relationships Really Impact Your Wallet
-
Terrence Howard Bashed For Rejecting Marvin Gaye Biopic Over Gay Kiss Scene
-
Simone Biles Accepts The 2025 TIME100 Impact Award For Mental Health Advocacy
-
Why Women Get The 'Ick' More Than Men — It Might Just Prolong Their Lives
-
Wowzer! 10 Sex Games To Build Trust And Intimacy With Your Partner
-
Here's Why You Should Never Pee In The Shower, According To Health Experts